6

I'd like to integrate a Drupal webform on a non-CiviCRM install with a Drupal CiviCRM install on a separate server. It seems to me that using a stripped down kind of module like webform-civicrm using a REST interface with CiviCRM might be a feasible option, stripping out some of the more complex integrations that require any native Civi code.

Has anyone tried something like this?

| improve this question | |
2

Author of the module here...

Great question. I've forseen a need for this and have over the past few versions been stripping out sql queries and BAO calls when possible and replacing them with api calls. But that work is only around half done. And the low-hanging fruit has been picked. The remaining BAO/DAO calls are mostly still in there because there is no equivalent api.

The reason for this approach is that CiviCRM supports api calls over REST, so once we decoupled Webform-CiviCRM from calling internal Civi functions, it would be theoretically possible to pipe all the api calls over REST (assuming you had a nice fast connection between the two servers).

The only "quick 'n easy" way forward I see would be to install CiviCRM on your host Drupal site just so the internal function calls won't bomb, then swap the wf_civicrm_api function in utils.inc to use REST. That should more-or-less work, depending on your use-case.

The "correct" solution is probably to write a CiviCRM extension, installable on the source site, that provides an api wrapper for all required internal functions, and patch Webform-CiviCRM to use that api instead of direct DAO/BAO calls. This would, in theory, allow you to host CiviCRM on WordPress and integrate with a Drupal webform.

| improve this answer | |
  • Do you think a smaller project as I outlined would be feasible? I.e. a stripped down version of webform civicrm that could be installed without CiviCRM on a remote site that accesses CiviCRM entirely by REST? The key question is - are there any non-api CiviCRM access points that are essential? Or are the points where you need BAO/whatever calls the exception for some of the more complicated stuff? At this point, I just need a fairly simple integration to do CRUD functions on contacts. So, a webform civicrm "lite". – Alan Dixon Mar 13 '17 at 18:21
  • Grepping for CRM_* in the code brings up 100+ uses, from accessing constants to making database queries. So is it possible to write a remote version of the module? Yes, but it would probably be a 50 hr project to get a "lite" version up and running. – Coleman Mar 14 '17 at 1:01
2

you may want to have a look at CiviMcRestFace (yes, that's really the name...). The project aims at providing an infrastructure for the data exchange between a public facing website with a CiviCRM system. It i still in a preliminary phase but feel free to get in contact with Erik Hommel or Björn Endres.

| improve this answer | |
  • That looks more aspirational that actual, yes? I didn't really want to get that abstracted and lost in a bigger project. – Alan Dixon Mar 13 '17 at 18:18
  • Well it's definitely not "plug and play" but it's base has been used in at least one (webform) project (github.com/systopia/ica_event_cmrf_connector). Also if you are likely to invest a lot of time to connect your external page it may be worth contributing to the project in order to enhance maintainability as well as re-usability. – Fabian Mar 14 '17 at 7:26
  • Ah, I see now, thanks, that does look like a worthwhile approach for this problem. – Alan Dixon Mar 15 '17 at 18:44

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.