Our site is configured to send a scheduled reminder 1 day after the membership expiration date. Memberships are renewed through a contribution page. The reminder is only sent to non-auto renew members. When a member renews their membership it updates the expiration date to the following year but the reminders are still being sent.
For example, A member's membership end date was October 14th, 2019. She renewed her membership on September 24th, 2019 which changed her membership end date to October 14th, 2020 but she still received a scheduled reminder on October 15, 2019.
Has anyone else experienced this issue? From my understanding, the scheduled reminder and contribution page is configured correctly.