If your existing members are getting a new recurring contribution you could potentially check for a new recurring contribution instead of a new membership? I think that would solve the issue.
If you try and it does not you might try something like:
a first rule to check for relevant new memberships and add them to a group
a second rule that adds them to a ...
I'm guessing Twilio is one of the cheapest and you're already set up with them, but if you'd consider RingCentral at about 1.7c/page which is reasonable then you can still keep Twilio for other things and just use RingCentral's email-to-fax plan.
So you'd add an email address on your contact records something like firstname.lastname@example.org, and then use it the ...
Yes it's intentional that there are no links if there's mixed record types in a profile.
It's been like that for a LONG time:
Also for reference:
UPDATE: Based on the comments, I think this is what is desired:
Create a profile ...